Baldur's Gate Pacifist Run - Nashkel

Whether you arrived in Nashkel via the northern Coast Way, or were automatically taken to Nashkel's Helm Temple to be rewarded for breaking Commander Brage's curse (see previous section on the Sword Coast), there's quite a few things you can do here:

Nashkel is seeing dark times due to the iron crisis, the threat of impending war between Amn and Baldur's Gate, and the reputed presence of "demons" who have been taking the lives of hardworking miners inside the Nashkel Mines, which you'll find southeast of this map. If you arrived in Nashkel via the northern roads, you'll meet a soldier who will tell you about the formerly well-respected Commander Brage who went berserk and disappeared into the wilderness, causing morale to diminish even further. (Our solution to the Brage case was described in the previous post on the Sword Coast.)

There is also an inn at the north of the town, but if you walk inside it, you'll be approached by another evil bounty hunter named Neira, who wants to kill you for the recently raised bounty on the head of Gorion's ward (your player character).

There is also a store next door to the inn down the main street where you can buy or sell. (The "quest" there isn't pacifist challenge-friendly since he just offers more gold than normal for the pelts of slain Winter Wolves.)

Berrun Ghastkill

Whether you arrived via the road or by being transported to the Helm Temple via Brage's quest, you'll meet Berrun Ghastkill standing near the path through the graveyard toward the Temple.

He will tell you about the many dark shadows over the town, and offer you a reward if you can figure out the source of the trouble coming from somewhere inside the depths of the Nashkel Mines. (This is the main storyline quest you'll need to complete eventually, covered in detail upcoming sections.)

Oublek the Bounty Administrator: 

Just down the road from Berrun Ghastkill and the cemetery, you'll find a large man named Oublek who will initially mistake you for a Bounty Hunter named Greywolf. If you're honest and say he's mistaken you for someone else, you'll receive an increase in your reputation. (If you lied, the implication is that you might be able to take some gold owed to Greywolf, but we didn't test it.)

After you speak with him again, he'll tell you about which bounties are currently available:

Oublek would normally have a bounty on the head of Commander Brage, but if you helped Brage turn himself in to the Temple of Helm by solving his riddle (see Sword Coast section) you won't be able to claim any extra reward from Oublek. (We never tested the option that would require killing, but the xp for helping Brage turn himself into the Helm Temple to break the curse reportedly gives you twice the reward of xp you would have gotten if you'd killed him, and possibly also twice the gold— so the nonviolent path actually seems to offer greater rewards in this case.)

The Bounty on Prism's Emeralds

The second bounty is on several emeralds which a sculptor named Prism apparently stole before becoming a fugitive. 

You'll find Prism by traveling to one map east of  Nashkel and heading to the southwestern part of the same map that contains the entrance to the Nashkel Mines (the rest of which are covered in their own section). You'll find Prism near a rock outcrop there, and see that he's carved the visage of an Elven Queen into the stone. Unfortunately, it turns out that Prism got carried away by his passions when completing his masterpiece and stole two emeralds to use for the eyes.

The pacifist run problem here seems to be that there is no nonviolent way (as far as we know) to solve this by speaking with Prism: If you talk to him and learn his story, the bounty hunter Greywolf will show up with the intention to kill Prism for the bounty on the emeralds. You'd consequently be forced to directly or indirectly dispatch Greywolf if you wanted to help Prism, after which Prism would die also (his exertions apparently having already taken a toll on his health). 

A mischievous but nonviolent alternative (contributed by our halfling thief player) is to simply pickpocket Prism without even talking to him to obtain both emeralds, and then return to Oublek to claim the bounty. 

The normal reward appears to be a few hundred gold pieces and 200 xp for turning in both emeralds. However, it's also possible to drop one of the emeralds on the ground before talking to Oublek to claim the same amount of gold and xp for a single emerald, and then pocketing the other emerald to be sold for a substantial price at any shop.

(Of course, if pickpocketing Prism rubs you the wrong way you could also just leave Prism and his emeralds alone: Greywolf won't ever show up unless you talk to Prism near the sculpture first.)

Minsc & The Quest to the Gnoll Stronghold

You'll meet an interesting Ranger named Minsc who has a pet hamster named Boo he takes everywhere with him. Minsc is on a quest to save his charge Dynaheir from the Gnoll Stronghold in the eastern Cloudpeak Mountains, where she's being held prisoner. 

You can recruit Minsc if you want, and he has solid strength that would make you easily able to carry away a lot of treasure when you venture into the Cloudpeak Mountains to seek out the Gnoll Stronghold. 

You can also rescue Dynaheir without ever recruiting Minsc, and then bring her back to be reunited with him later, if you prefer. (If you don't want to divide xp from saving Dynaheir in multiple ways, you'd just need to be careful to temporarily remove any members you didn't want to cut in on the reward. The upcoming sections on Cloudpeak Mountains and the Gnoll Stronghold have details.)

Joseph's House

If you travel to the southeasternmost corner of the map just down from a large pond, you'll find a house where a miner's wife lives (along with her sick elderly mother): She'll tell you her husband Joseph disappeared weeks ago, and that you can identify him by his greenstone ring if you go asking after him. Unfortunately there's no way we know of to bring about a happy ending here, since you'll find Joseph's body inside the Nashkel Mines, but if you bring the Greenstone Ring back to his wife, you'll be rewarded 800 xp for doing your best to help. 

Noober

On a lighter pacifist run note: After you cross the bridge just south of the Belching Dragon Tavern, you'll meet a local man named Noober. Noober will confide that most people find him irritating, and that many even throw rocks at him for this reason. 

If you persist in talking to Noober repeatedly (disregarding any opprobrious remarks he makes, such as "Those colors look really stoo-pid on you"), you should reach a point where he will ask if you're going to throw rocks at him, after which he will begin to intermittently ask "What about now?" over and over again as you just walk around near him (i.e. without having to click on him to re- start the dialogue yourself). After a minute or two of this exercise, Noober will remark that you're very patient, and that he can't think of anything else to say— after which he'll walk away and you'll receive 400 xp (which is a solid gain for a modest-level pacifist challenger).

The Ankheg Armor

Fortunately you won't encounter Ankhegs in the farmland here, but if you travel all the way to the far western tilled field, you can find a hidden stash (specifically at coordinates X:187, Y:2742) containing a pearl and some very powerful armor crafted out of an Ankheg's shell: 

This armor will make any warrior-class character much tougher at withstanding damage if worn, and is also worth a lot of gold. (The only other way you could obtain such armor would be to break the pacifist challenge rules by killing an Ankheg and then paying thousands of gold pieces to Taerom Fuirum at the Thunderhammer Smithy to craft a set for you.)

Other optional areas of interest in Nashkel: 

You can visit the Belching Dragon Tavern in the south/central part of the map (on the east side of the river) to meet the famous travelling bard Volothamp Geddarm, who will tell you many stories (including background plot information about the troubles at the Nashkel Mines, and Commander Brage and the cursed sword) if you buy him some ale.

On the dark side: If you click one of the gravestones beneath an obelisk in the cemetary, you will be confronted by a being named Daer'Ragh who will tell you not to disturb him (and apparently if you do it again, he'll summon some formidable adversaries to attack you).

There is also a Conjurer of "lawful evil" alignment named Edwin standing near the bridge on this map. He'll say he wants to hire you to murder a mage Dynaheir for reasons he refuses to explain, but you can safely just ignore him and refuse. (He'll apparently join the band if you agree, but as far as we know he can't ever actually make you harm anyone even then, though having evil aligned NPCs in your band may cause other problems we're not aware of.)

The only other useful things we found that didn't involve violence were a handful of locks to open for xp (as usual, without actually having to steal anything inside).  While the yield of xp per lock is very small at around 10xp, our halfling thief actually encountered the problem of being less than 100 points from a level-up, so in a run where he wasn't allowed to fight any monsters for xp, opening these locks did actually make the critical difference at this point:

On the path that begins just east of the Garrison and winds up between landscaped trees and vegetation, you can find a mansion and "invite yourself in" to meet some nobles who are unhappy to see you, and (reportedly) also a scene in which a woman named Samantha might let her lover out of a closet to attack you under certain circumstances.

The other place to find some locks is inside the Garrison building behind where Minsc is standing. One of the soldiers will approach and talk tough to try to intimidate you when you go inside, but if you choose the tough-talking confrontational dialogue option (regardless of how small and weak your pacifist run character may actually be), the soldier will promptly change his mind, apologize, and leave you alone. 

You are then free to pick the various locked chests to acquire 10xp per lock, which won't cause the guards to attack you unless you actually tried to open a chest (which would immediately make them confront you and either attack you or demand to be paid off with bribes.)

A halfling thief scrounging for pacifist run xp manages a level-up by picking locks for 10xp each.

Baldur's Gate Pacifist Run - The Sword Coast

This section covers all three maps directly following the western Sword Coast:
In addition to some nice coastal scenery, you can find some great pacifist run treasures in a sea cave, complete some interesting encounters and one easy nonviolent quest, and also find a quest further south that will automatically transport you to Nashkel when it concludes for a reward of 1000 xp, making this our preferred route to reach Nashkel before continuing the investigation of the mines.

The Sword Coast & The Shipwreck (one map east of High Hedge)
This is the furthest northern coastal map you can reach, since sheer cliffs cut it off from Candlekeep, and the other seaside areas are inside Cloakwood and Baldur's Gate (neither of which you can reach until later chapters).

If you run into a nereid named Shoal in the central northern part of the map, she will try to deliver a cursed kiss that will kill any player who receives it. After a skirmish (which she'll give up on shortly), it turns out she is being held captive and obliged to do this by "Ogre-Droth," after which she'd raise the ally she killed and try to get you to kill him to release her. To do this, you'd have to rely on a compromise like charming other creatures in the area to dispatch Ogre Droth, in which case you could free Shoal for a reward. (But you won't need to do this if you don't want to get involved.)

Mad Arcand and the Shipwreck

Heading west to where the rocky cliffs meet the sea (southwest of where Shoal is, if you encountered her), you will find a riddling gnome named Mad Arcand.

 Fortunately, he'll like you, and ask you to bring his his cursed "Ring of Folly" from a nearby shipwreck. You'll find the shipwreck just a short distance southwest at the edge of the sea, and can take the ring. (Don't put the ring on, however, as it's cursed.)

When you give the cursed Ring of Folly back to Mad Arcand, he'll thank you and give you an "Oil of Fiery Burning" and 300 xp. 

Note there is a huge "Carrion Crawler" that will chase you on this strand unless you're using stealth, and might pen you into a narrow area if you're not careful— but as usual the Baldur's Gate monsters aren't any threat to NPCs outside your own band, so you don't have to worry about Mad Arcand getting attacked by it.

The Brother of Davaeorn

You can meet a character known as "The Surgeon" in the lower part of this map, who will tell you that he is the brother of a powerful mage named Davaeorn, who has long since turned to evil and killed many, including their own father. He'll give you a Potion of Magic Protection in the event you should ever confront Davaeorn yourself.

The Sea Cave & Abandoned Lighthouse

This stretch of the Sword Coast is the site where a an old abandoned lighthouse stands over a cove with a few small sandy beaches. This stretch of coast is an excellent place to visit on a pacifist run because of the sea cave on the north side of the cove, described in detail below.

There is also someone you can recruit here, if you're looking for another thief: A young woman named Safana, who you can find on the western side in the center of the map. Safana will pretend to be in awe of your male party members in order to try to persuade you to protect her on a quest to raid pirate treasures from a dangerous cave at the cove. 

Not far from Safana, there is also an astrologer you can talk to a little ways north, and a gypsy aways south who will offer to read your palm for some gold, but will then become upset by what she sees and won't want to tell you anymore. 

The Old Lighthouse

If you traveled all the way southwest to the lighthouse, you'd find a woman named Ardrouine who says her son went exploring the lighthouse ruin, but has now been surrounded by worgs that gathered at the base of the light house, so that he won't come down. We tried to solve this, but unfortunately found that even after we lead all worgs far from the lighthouse, charmed them, and also tested rendering them unconscious with Sleep and Color Spray spells, the son still won't seem to come out of the lighthouse no matter how little danger remains. (So there's probably no way to complete this quest without causing deaths.)

The Cove & The Sea Cave

The sea cave you can find on this map is full of useful pacifist run treasures, but the cave is guarded by fairly dangerous Sirines. You can reach the cave by going to the central western part of the map, where you'll find a large sandy beach, though you'll have to use stealth or other tactics to get past some hobgoblin bandits and archers lurking in the area. 

You'll then be able to follow the cove on the north side until you reach another sandy beach, above which you can travel north a ways to reach the mouth of the sea cave containing a hoard of pirate treasure.

However, you'll also be threatened by Sirines south of the cave:

Probably the best way to get past the Sirines is to use stealth or invisibility to sneak past them, so that their leader, Sil, never sees you: If you succeed, then Sil won't open the dialogue to tell you that it is "not your place" here (after which she summons more sirines to attack you). 

The main reason the sirines are dangerous is because they can cast Dire Charm and cause your own characters to be out of your control while the spell lasts, as well as becoming a danger to your own allies. (Sil and the sirines also cast a higher-level invisibility spell on themselves, but that won't be a problem for a pacifist challenger with no intention to attack them in the first place.)

By this time (after visiting High Hedge) we always had the invisibility spell for the mage/enchanters, and decent stealth skills for the rogue/thief characters, so sneaking past them the first time allowed us to get inside the sea cave without being seen.

Inside the cave, you'll find many passages leading in various directions, and discover that the caves are guarded by at least two flesh golems (as well as lots of harmless bats fluttering in the caverns that won't attack). You can circle around the caves in several directions, but the paths are narrow, so it's much better to avoid being seen by using stealth, if possible. 

The treasure hoard is in a large stone jutting from a pool on the northwestern side of the cave. One of the flesh golems sometimes lumbers up here, but by waiting awhile, we found that he'd just leave and stomp back down toward the south caves after a short time. 

The hoard of pirate treasure: 

In order to grab the treasure, you'll need someone to break out of invisibility, assuming you used stealth to get inside the cave. (A rogue/thief that can then re-conceal themselves without wasting an invisibility spell might be best, and you can pass the treasures to your allies without breaking their invisibility status.)

The hoard of pirate treasure contains over 300 gold pieces, some valuable potions, some darts, and three excellent pacifist run treasures: 

One is a Wand of Paralyzation that will freeze enemies in place without harming them, and in many cases works better than the similarly useful Wand of Sleep, including against key boss-like NPCs you'll encounter later.

The second is the "Cloak of the Wolf," which will allow the wearer to transform into a wolf for a period of time, and consequently move as quickly as one, which might be helpful to escape some situations.

The third is a "Manual of Bodily Health," which will give you a permanent +1 to the Constitution of whoever reads it, though it can only be used once. (This is still very good, since in Baldur's Gate your attribute scores typically stay the same after character generation, rather than giving you more attribute points to allocate at level-ups.)

The Flesh Golems in the sea cave seemed to be immune to spells like Sleep and Color Spray, so when you're ready to escape, it would be ideal to re-cast invisibility on anyone who isn't hidden in shadows. This would also help to avoid letting Sil see you outside the cave, and summon the other sirines to attack you for setting foot on their beach. (We did this with a mage who had run out of invisibility castings  and almost got killed, but managed to resist the Charm spell and still managed to get away from the Sirines even after Sil attacked us.)

When you're ready to leave this section of the coast, you can reach the final map along the coast  by traveling to the south.

The Ancient Excavations & Commander Brage

(third map down the sword coast, south of the lighthouse)

After traveling south of the map with the sea cave and old lighthouse, you'll reach a remote area with some rocky crags of banded rock and lots of pine forests. Stealth is ideal here, because this area is heavily populated with Gnolls, wild beasts, Tasloi, and a hobgoblin bandit (and will later fill with even more dangerous foes, depending on your choices if you visit the Excavations). 

There are paths between two bands of forest on the western side of the map, and below that (where a dirt road turns further inland), there is a hobgoblin bandit to watch out for named Ba'Ruk. Ba'Ruk may not seem to be very smart, but if you let him speak and demand you give him all your gold,  he'll summon a large band of Kobold Commandos who fire dangerous flaming arrows that can easily slay 1-2 pacifist run characters with low HP in seconds. (If you avoid Ba'Ruk, though, the kobolds and their fire arrows probably never appear.)

The Ancient Excavations & Charleston Nib

If you head east toward the upper-central part of the map, you will find a site where a large group of diggers are unearthing an ancient stone settlement from beneath the cliffsides. 

They are led by an archeologist named Charleston Nib, who will tell you that they could use more protection due to night-raids by enemies in the wild surrounding area. If you agree to help Nib, you'll soon also be approached by a treacherous partner of Nib's named Gallor, who will propose that you kill Nib and split proceeds from any treasures discovered. We turned Gallor's offer down, and shortly after that Nib announced that his men were on the verge of penetrating into the main interior chambers of the ruin being unearthed...

You'll then be taken inside the ruins automatically, into some cave-like old chambers where a disturbing stone idol of an evil god  named Kozah will be found. At this point (with no way to avert it that we know of) Nib's diggers will become taken over by the extant powers of evil emanating from the idol, and will start to attack you in force. 

The good news is that the diggers won't harm Nib at all, but there doesn't seem to be any way to bring this entire scenario to conclusion by removing the curse without being forced to slay the otherwise-innocent diggers that have been bewitched.

However, you can steal the idol of Koza (stone idol) and take it with you, then give the diggers the slip and run away without killing anyone.  

As soon as you leave the ruins with the idol, a dark undead entity called a "Doomsayer" will confront you and seem to be indicating in an ancient language that it wants the idol, but there didn't seem to be a way to make it dispel the curse by giving the idol back to it, so the only remaining option seemed to be to run away.  

(The only use we know of for the idol itself, by the way, is to  combine it with some other things at the Ruins of Ulcaster in order to receive a vampiric sword from Ulcaster's ghost. The stone idol is otherwise only worth a small amount of gold.)

Commander Brage & The Journey to Nashkel

Whether or not you are being chased by the bewitched diggers and hostile Doomsayer from the Excavations (which you could choose to skip), you will find the remains of a grisly scene southeast of the Excavations, in a large dirt clearing. 

On the way there, you'll likely meet a cousin of Commander Brage's named Laryssa, who will tell you to stay away from Brage, as he has gone berserk and slain many, including his own family. 

Unfortunately there is no way we know of to revive any of the dead family members or others who have been slain, but it turns out that Brage has actually been bewitched by a cursed sword, and there is a way you can put a stop to further evils by talking to him above the scene of carnage: 

Brage will tell you a macabre riddle (to which the answer is "Death"), and when you solve the riddle, he will temporarily be restored to sanity, and ask you to take him to the Temple of Helm to face execution for his crimes, which he never wanted to commit. 

If you agree to this, you'll automatically be transported all the way to the Temple of Helm in Nashkel immediately (regardless of how many enemies from elsewhere on the map might be actively chasing and attacking you), and the priest of Helm there will remove the cursed sword. The priest will also persuade the grief-stricken Brage that his life still has purpose by serving Helm to atone for his crimes, since it was never his own will to commit any of the atrocities.

As for your role in ending the evils: You'll be awarded with 1000 gold and  1000 xp, as well as  increased reputation and a strength potion, along with the cursed sword that caused all these evils to begin with.

Baldur's Gate Pacifist Run: Journey to Beregost

As far as we know, you can arrive in Beregost at any time after leaving Candlekeep, after journeying south, though our preference was to get the extra pacifist run levels from the Wyrm's Crossing Area covered in the previous post first.

Beregost is two maps south of the Friendly Arms Inn

If you approach from the north, you'll probably meet a friendly man named Golin Vend who will offer directions to nearby inns and the famous Thunderhammer Smithy run by blacksmith Taerom Fuiruim. But the path toward the highest rewards of nonviolent xp probably begins with heading to the Feldepost Inn, followed by a quick trip across the street to Firebead Elvenhair's house:

The Feldepost Inn

If you head south down the street past the large obelisk and the Town Crier (who is delivering news about a bounty on a mad cleric named Bassilus, who has turned to necromancy), you'll soon come to Feldepost's Inn. 

On the first floor, you'll be confronted by an angry farmer named Marl who will tell you to get out of the Inn, since adventurers aren't welcome there, according to him. If you talk to him again, he'll be confrontational, and you'll learn that he's upset because his son (who also wanted to become an adventurer) was recently killed.

You'll be given five dialogue choices at various points, and the sequence to calm Marl down (regardless of how well they really fit your own RPG player character's personality) are: #1: first choice, #2: first choice again, #3: third choice, #4: third choice, #5: first choice.)

Marl's friend Dunkin (who initially said "You tell 'em Marl") will chime in to side with you in the process of these, telling Marl that the son was already determined to become an adventurer and never wanted to settle down and farm, as Marl seems to want to believe. If you follow the sequence above ending with offering to buy Marl a drink in honor of the son's memory, Marl will not attack you, and you'll receive 900 experience points.

Other things to do at the Inn: There is a humorous drunken noblewoman named Gyllian you can talk to optionally, an innkeeper who will rent rooms and buy and sell items, and a second floor that doesn't contain anything crucial until later. If you want to be efficient, you can also buy a book called "The History of the Fateful Coin" for a very modest price from the innkeeper before heading over to Firebead Elvenhair's House. 

On the second floor of the Inn, there is also a large man named Algernon who can famously be pick pocketed for a pink cloak that provides its wearer +2 charisma, but you don't need to steal if you don't want to: You can cast a mage spell called "Friends" to increase CHA by about six points temporarily on any occasion where a high CHA score is important, and also find a skill manual elsewhere that will grant you more charisma without having to steal.

(Later on you'll eventually also find an important character on the second floor of the Inn after you complete the Nashkel Mines, but he won't show up here until after completing the Nashkel Mines.)

Firebead Elvenhair's House

You'll find your old friend from Candlekeep at his house across the street from the Feldepost Inn, slightly southeast of the Inn entrance. He will be glad to invite you in (i.e. not consider you an intruder if you just walk into his house), and give you a small quest to bring him a recently published tome called "The History of the Fateful Coin", which you should be able to buy at Feldepost's Inn right across the street. Doing this will reward you with 300 xp and increased reputation.

Other places in Beregost: There are a number of quests you can get from Beregost and complete elsewhere without killing anything, if you're willing to do a bit of travel and use the Charm enchantment spell + the pickpocket spell to steal stolen items back from various bandits, such as hobgoblins, gnolls, and tasloi. 

The Burning Wizard Inn

This inn is in the center of town, and you'll notice it because a bard in yellowish clothing is standing outside it: This is Garrick, who can theoretically join your band, but the problem is that recruiting him might require you to cause someone's death, so we didn't try. (See below in the section re: Garrick and Silke Rosena.)

Meanwhile, inside the Burning Wizard Inn: You can find a halfling thief named Zhurlong on the first floor, who will tell you that he's angry because some hoboblin bandits stole his Boots of Stealth. After he gives you the details, he'll tell you he's spotted the legendary drow Drizzt Do'Urden as a distraction, and  pickpocket you for 15 gold— but if you bring him back his boots he'll apologize and give you 100 gold + the 15 he stole from you, and better yet you'll receive 300 xp.

Recovering Zhurlong's Boots: 

This is another quest you can do nonviolently, whenever you're ready to travel to the forested area on the road south of Beregost: You'll find the bandits in the eastern part of the map a short distance below a dark cave in a crag of rock. 

You can cast Charm on him and then send your thief to pickpocket him to steal back the boots, then choose your methods to send him lumbering off into the woods, and/or cast Sleep or Color Spray.

(Be careful where you aim your Color Spray, however, as one of our players accidentally temporarily made Imoen swoon with it along with the hobgoblins. Fortunately the Enchanter was also able to incapacitate the other hobgoblins with sleep spells long enough to hold them off until she woke up and they both escaped.)

Before bringing back Zhurlong's Boots of Stealth right away: These items are highly valuable to any thief because they add a large number of points to your Hide in Shadows and Move Silently skills (which are averaged to impact your success with hiding in the shadows to move unseen by enemies). 

You can also find a pair of Boots of Stealth on another hobgoblin bandit in the southern part of the map containing the Ruins of Ulcaster later and obtain those in the same way (i.e. Charm + pickpocketing the charmed hobgoblin bandit to steal the boots), so it might be a good idea to wait until later to give Zhurlong back his pair. (After all, you already put down a "deposit" with him of the 15 gold he stole from you at the Burning Wizard.)

Garrick & Silke Rosena

If you talk to Garrick outside the Burning Wizard Inn, he'll say his employer Silke Rosena (apparently a noteworthy travelling performer) is looking for bodyguards. We didn't find a way to deal with this situation peacefully, but the good news is that no one else is actually in any danger (other than you) if you refuse to assist Rosena: 

After Garrick takes you to where she is waiting outside the Red Sheaf Inn, she'll claim she's being threatened by thugs and offer you some gold to kill them on site, but when they approach, they'll greet her courteously and try to say that they've brought her some gems she requested to buy. Silke will try to cut them off and yell at you to strike and kill them immediately, but if you refuse and try to ask questions first, she'll became angry and attack you with magic spells. (The three gem merchants will just stand around doing nothing during this episode, by the way, even if you take their side.)

You'd be able to get away from Silke despite the dangers of her spells, but since there isn't any way to deal with her peacefully that we know of, you might be better off never bothering to talk to Garrick about the "job" she offers. (Since she isn't very nice, you also have the option of pickpocketing her for at least one valuable potion even if you never let her try to recruit you to kill the merchants, since she'll still be standing around outside the Red Sheaf Inn.)

While on the subject of recruitable NPCs: There is also an evil dwarf mercenary named Kagain that you can recruit at his shop in Beregost (just above the Feldepost Inn) if you wanted to, but we didn't recruit him either since evil ax-wielding characters didn't fit in with our pacifist run plans. 

The Red Sheaf Inn

This inn is right down the road east of the Burning Wizard in the center of town, where Silke Rosena is standing.

Warning: Before going inside, be aware that there is a dwarf hitman named Karlat inside. While reasonably polite by assassin's standards, Karlat won't be receptive to any negotiations or counter-offers, and will try to kill you after talking to you regardless of what you say to him.

One option you can use if you have a solo thief with solid stealth skills and/or a mage with invisibility spells is to walk past Karlat invisible, if you want to do anything else in the Inn without him chasing you around, since he is strong and can do a lot of damage if you let him get close enough to strike. 

Another peaceful method that worked to get Karlat permanently out of the way without harming anyone: Unlike the two thieves who tried to kill you at Candlekeep, but wouldn't leave the buildlings they were hiding in, Karlat is more determined and will chase you inside and outside other buildings trying to get you. You can use this to your advantage if you have either a thief and/or mage: 

First get Karlat to chase you out of the Inn and into another house (or perhaps just the upper floor of the Red Sheaf where you first find him, but a a two-story house was used in our case). 

If you then hide in the shadows successfully upstairs (e.g. by hiding in a sideroom or behind a wall partition out of sight) or cast invisibility, Karlat will become confused and stay in the building where he lost track of you, and you can leave while you're still hidden in the shadows (or invisible) without him trying to follow you anymore.

Perdue's Shortsword

The main reason to go into the Red Sheaf is to talk to Perdue, another angry halfling whose shortsword was stolen from him by Gnoll bandits outside the wizard's keep called High Hedge in the west. 

To get the quest, you'll again have to choose some dialogue options that might not be optimal for your own character: #1: the first choice, #2: the second, #3: the first again, and #4: the first yet again. This should give you the quest to recover Perdue's stolen short-sword. 

You'll find the gnolls who have it on the eastern side of High Hedge, the map southwest of Beregost: 

The gnolls are lurking on the southeast side of the stone keep, but happily they're all quite susceptible to the level 1 charm, sleep, and color spray spells, so the tactic of subduing some of them without injury and charming and pick-pocketing the one with the sword should work again.

Gnolls slumbering peacefully after the casting of a Sleep spell...

After the correct gnoll is charmed, you can use the usual trick of using the pick-pocketing skill on the gnoll repeatedly until it succeeds, since a charmed creature won't become hostile after a failed pick-pocketing attempt:

Our thief using the pick pocket skill repeatedly on the charmed gnoll

You'll probably end up with gold and other miscellaneous items the gnolls have on them as well, but you can just check your inventory while the game's paused to make sure you eventually got Perdue's Short Sword before the charm spell wears off.

Checking our thief's inventory to make sure we got Perdue's short sword

Preventing the gnolls from hewing into each other with their halberds after at least one of them gets charmed is slightly trickier, but not difficult if you have the patience to keep sending them away from each other to keep them separated each time they try to re-initiate an attack on each other. (Watch out about taking too many side trips, however, as there are hostile skeletons lurking in the woods a little way to the west, as well as lots more gnolls lurking south of High Hedge.)

We sent the gnoll to take a walk in flowery meadows here, shortly before the Charm spell wore off and we had to run away to Beregost with both the gnoll and a gang of skeletons in pursuit...

When you return to the Red Sheaf Inn and give Perdue his shortsword, you'll receive some gold and 500 experience points.

Thunderhammer Smithy & The Shadow Armor

Inside the Thunderhammer Smithy you will find Taerom Fuiruim the blacksmith. He has many high-priced items for sale, but if you have a thief/rogue on your team, you will be able to give a huge boost to your stealth skills by buying the "Shadow Armor" for a high price here. On a pacifist run it's well worth the gold to boost your stealth skill by the amount the Shadow Armor grants, since you can repeatedly retry hiding in the shadows until your thief becomes invisible again (making it much easier to do things like grab items from chests in dungeons, and then re-hide your character without having to rest, like a mage with limited invisibility spells would). Boosting your stealth with the Shadow Armor and Boots of Stealth will also let you apply more scarce pacifist run level-up skill points into other thief skills.

The Jovial Juggler Inn

Gurke's Cloak

An old dwarf named Gurke is stamping around the first floor of the Inn and is irate because a band of tasloi from the Cloakwood Forest stole his cloak. 

It will be awhile before you can claim it since you'll have to visit Cloakwood Forest (and most versions of the game won't let you enter Cloakwood until a later chapter), but when you can go there: You'll find the cloak on one of many tasloi, and can use the combination of Charm + pickpocketing to steal back the cloak without killing any of them.

Gurke's Cloak is potentially valuable later in the game: It is a magic cloak that will prevent you from being detected by mages. But fortunately you won't have to struggle with temptation to "steal" the Cloak by omitting to return it to Gurke, since Gurke will actually ask you to keep it for yourself if you try to return it to him— so you'll get to keep it and also be rewarded with 300xp for completing the quest. (See the upcoming section on Cloakwood for the details on grabbing the cloak from the band of Tasloi without having to use violence.)

The other encounters in the Jovial Juggler were amusing but we didn't find any further rewards on a pacifist run from them: There is a paladin named Bjornin who was attacked by some half-ogrish brigands southwest of Beregost and wants someone to pay them back with some of their own medicine, but you won't be able to deal with them in a pacifist run since he just wants them defeated in combat. You can also meet a man named Oogie Wisham upstairs, who appears convinced that Bjornin is a zealous inquisitor out to get him— though there's no other indication that this is the case, or that the paladin is even aware of Wisham's presence.

Landrin's House

If you met the old gnome Landrin on the upper floors of the Friendly Arms Inn, you'll find her house just west of the Jovial Juggler, behind a small fence near some tree. 

The house of Landrin, the gnome currently taking refuge at the Friendly Arms Inn

You can enter the house and quickly grab her old boots and wine to take back to her for several hundred xp each (and some gold), but be warned that the spiders inside will immediately attack. 

Warning: If you decide to take on the spiders without incapacitating them with a nonviolent spell like Color Spray, they can also quickly spill out the door and trap you if you're not careful. 

One last Beregost side quest we didn't find a pure pacifist run solution for: 

In a house a little ways north of the Thunderhammer Smithy, there is a woman named Mirianne who is concerned about the lack of news of her husband Roe. It turns out that he already sent her a letter, but ogrillons killed the messenger carrying the letter on the road south of Beregost, and stole it.

Unfortunately Ogrillons (as well as ogres) seem to be immune to Charm spells, so we didn't find a nonviolent way to get back the letter, so skipped it on our run. If you prefer to set Mirianne's mind at ease by charming other creatures to defeat the Ogrillions, though, you'd be rewarded with 300 xp and another Ring of Protection.